Issue 62

Table of Contents
Number 62
Summer 2009

BUNGALOW FEATURES

Willo 1: Finding Willo
by Katherine Bair Desmond
An eclectic Phoenix historic district
has a way of making friends

COLLECTIONS
Left Brain, Wright Brain 50.
by David Cathers
Years of collecting furniture from
L. & J.G. Stickley led Donald Davidoff
and Susan Tarlow to appreciate the
affinity between it and Frank Lloyd
Wright’s Prairie aesthetic.

HISTORIC NEIGHBORHOODS
America the Way It’s Supposed to Be: Toledo’s Old West End 68
By Douglas J. Forsyth
The Old West End’s intact architectural
heritage has helped its residents create a .
prospering multiracial, multicultural
“Bohemia of Northwest Ohio.”

Willo 2: Bungalow renovation
Space, Time and Home:
An Architect’s Family Story 86
By Diane Reicher Jacobs, AIA
Heeding both their professional ethic
and their respect for their historic
neighborhood, Diane and Michael Jacobs
expanded their tiny bungalow just enough to.
cheerfully embrace their young family.

My Word
Smart Growth, Green Building
and Other Oxymorons 100
By Jane Powell
In which the author asks what is “green”
about expending enormous amounts of
energy tearing down 100-year-old buildings
to make way for shiny new ones.

DEPARTMENTS AND CRAFTSMAN RESOURCES

A Letter from the Publisher 1

Open House: Letters to the Editor 8
Was it the Devil at my door? And about
those mugs ….

Family Album 16.
From coast to coast, readers share their
bungalow restoration and preservation
achievements.

Antiques
Perspective on Antiques 22
with David Rudd
Our consultant responds to readers’
questions on vintage furnishings.

New & Noteworthy 29
A selection of Arts and Crafts–inspired
amenities for contemporary living.

Arts & Crafts Profile
Weaving the Past for the Present 106
By John Luke
Paul Freeman is “The Textile Guy” and
has the goods to prove it.

BOOKS
The Hoosier Cabinet in Kitchen History 111
By Nancy R. Hiller
Review by John Luke

American Bungalow News 113 .
A busy summer tour season ahead. But first,
historic preservation and the Stimulus Plan,
and Robert Winter gets his due … again.

From Our Friends
Kilmore, Victoria, Australia:
February, 2009 124
By Steve Ansell
In a time of extremity, a magazine’s arrival affirms life.

Directory of Advertisers 125

The Bungalow Bookstore 127
Your reliable resource for Arts and Crafts
history, design and restoration.

By Katherine Bair Desmond
From Issue 62 (Summer 2009) – An eclectic Phoenix historic district has a way of making friends.

When my husband suggested a relocation to Phoenix four years ago to be nearer to his family, visions of endless identical postwar homes surrounded by dirt and cacti sprang to mind. For a girl who grew up in the green hills of Atlanta and has lived in the Berkshire mountains, Boston, Washington D.C. and London, the thought of a move to the desert was less than thrilling. The pace of life was appealing, as was the closeness to family. But could I ever feel at home in the desert landscape?

We decided to take a “get to know Phoenix” trip. Ryan drove me around to countless neighborhoods his mother had suggested we check out. None spoke to me. Many were nice—perfectly pleasant—but I needed a neighborhood with character. A neighborhood with soul. I started to think maybe you couldn’t find that in America’s “new” cities.
And then … we found Willo.

Covering approximately one square mile and situated in midtown Phoenix just two miles north of downtown, the Willo neighborhood is a breath of architectural fresh air. Prior to 1901, when the first subdivision was platted, the land was a privately held agricultural area. A second subdivision was platted in 1910. The bulk of the homes in the southern half of the neighborhood—including several blocks of bungalows—were constructed in the 1920s and ’30s, abetted by the introduction of a streetcar line that connected the area to downtown. But the Period Revival movement of the time meant homes were designed in a great variety of revival styles, including Tudor, Greek, American Colonial, Spanish Colonial and Pueblo, in addition to Classic and Craftsman Bungalow. The arrival of the Great Depression interrupted development briefly, but it soon resumed. And as air conditioning became widely available, more new homes sprang up. The additions continued until the 1950s, when the last homes were built.


Like many urban American neighborhoods, Willo experienced a period of slight deterioration as people flocked to the suburbs beginning in the 1960s. But the allure of the architectural variety, the vibrancy of the community and its proximity to the business and cultural centers of a thriving Phoenix were strong, and in the 1980s residents successfully lobbied for historic designation as a special conservation district. Over the last 20 years, the neighborhood has gone through its own revival as new individuals and families have moved in and long-time residents have continued to maintain their homes.

Ryan and I drove the streets of the neighborhood and decided to call a realtor. We didn’t have jobs lined up in Phoenix—we still thought we were just exploring—but we knew we had found the place we wanted to call home. Days later we visited an American Colonial Revival home. I remember pulling up in front for the first time—there were paper hearts hanging in the windows, obviously the project of a child getting ready for Valentine’s Day. I turned to Ryan. “This one’s got good karma,” I said.

When we walked through the doors, the karma followed. We entered a large living room that was open to the dining room behind it. The hardwood floors were gorgeous. Candles flickered above the original fireplace. Built-in decorative shelving along one wall held the family’s treasures. A step down to the dining room, between four columns, brought you just steps away from the backyard. The sun came in through the open windows (Phoenix in February!), and the views to the back were beautiful—a garden full of flowering bougainvillea, a brick patio covered by a lovely trellis, a raised planter where the kids grew vegetables for fun. It took our breath away.

A tour of the rest of the house—which didn’t take long, since it was a snug 1,400 square feet—convinced us this was the right first home for us. The kitchen was wide, light-filled and beautifully renovated. The master bedroom was uncharacteristically large. The guest bedroom was small, but, we asked ourselves, how much space do guests really need? The one full bathroom was petite but adequate.

The home office that I would use had gorgeous windows covering three of its four walls. It
had originally been a sleeping porch—a very common feature of homes built during this era in Phoenix. In the heat of the summer, families would sleep in open-air porches with damp sheets hung around the perimeter of the room. The evening breezes would cool the air with the humidity from the sheets—sort of an early swamp cooler. In later years, windows were added. I’ve never had an office with that much sunlight.

A day after that showing, we were back in Washington, faxing an offer letter and celebrating when we went into escrow. The business of finding jobs in Phoenix quickly sorted itself out, and we joyfully embarked on our cross-country move.

Vibrancy

We soon came to learn that what was so special about Willo was not just its architectural appeal but its vibrant sense of community.

The people of Willo don’t fit into any one mold. There are long-time residents who have lived here for decades. (My next-door neighbor still lives in the house where she spent her childhood.) Then there are those who have moved to Willo more recently—singles, couples, families. Take a walk through the neighborhood on any pleasant evening and you’ll run into dozens of neighbors—some out jogging, many walking their dogs, others pushing their children in strollers. It’s a “front porch” neighborhood. People sit outside, wave to their neighbors and invite them over for a glass of wine.

Two years after relocating to Phoenix, we were thrilled to learn that our family would be expanding to include a baby girl. Our daughter arrived about the time half a dozen or so other children were born in the neighborhood. We moms and dads see each other during our morning and evening walks, and we get together sometimes to talk about parenting in Phoenix. All of us have made the choice to raise our children in Willo because it’s such a unique, welcoming and supportive community. None of us can imagine raising our families anywhere else.

The residents are also active and engaged in neighborhood affairs. The Willo Neighborhood Association board meets monthly, and I’m always amazed at how many people show up, just to learn what’s going on and to get involved. On one Sunday each February the association puts on a highly regarded home tour that draws more than 3,000 visitors and 100 street-fair vendors. The event is a wonderful way to share our neighborhood with others in Phoenix and beyond, and it serves as the fund-raising event for the neighborhood’s upkeep, beautification and other improvements.

The home tour is also a way to get potential new residents interested in Willo. Our neighbors Denise and Jeremy Staley found out about the neighborhood by attending one of the tours. They decided to move from their suburban, “cookie-cutter” house to downtown Phoenix after about three hours in Willo. Denise says they fell in love with the character and charm of the historic district, a stark contrast to newer neighborhoods on the city’s outskirts.

Since moving here four years ago, the Staleys have also come to value the proximity to local restaurants, cultural activities and the new light rail system. Directly adjacent to Willo and connecting downtown with points north and with neighboring Tempe (home of Arizona State University), the light rail was recently unveiled and is changing the urban Phoenix landscape. The juxtaposition of this modern convenience with the historic charm of Willo only adds to the neighborhood’s unique appeal.

The Staleys’ home, built in the 1920s, is one of the relatively few bungalows in the neighborhood. It is fondly referred to as one of the “twin” bungalows. (Their neighbors on the other side, Stacie and David Taylor, live in the other one, and the couples have become fast friends.) It was built as cars were becoming more popular and important, and its large porte cochere is a distinctive feature of the facade. They love the multicolored brick used in its construction and the welcoming front porch. The home has all of its original built-in cabinetry, double-hung windows, coved ceilings, moldings and glass door knobs. They have renovated the kitchen with vintage tile and a period stove, and they’re currently at work on a rear addition that will house a master suite.

Like the Staleys, the Taylors also fell in love with Willo at one of the annual tours. They both grew up in older cities, so both really valued the unique character of the neighborhood. In 2003, when they were ready to buy their first home together, they knew they would find it in Willo. Stacie loves the unique brickwork in her bungalow, as well as the beautiful windows and eaves. She and David added a free-standing garage to the property that features the same Dutch gable as the 1,100-square-foot home. Echoing the sentiments of so many Willo residents, Stacie says, “It isn’t about the size of the home, it’s about its feeling. In Willo, the houses really feel like homes.”

Mary Peralta, another resident who has been an active presence in the Willo community, grew up in Phoenix. As a student at Phoenix College in the 1970s she rode her bike through Willo on her way to classes. She says the character and history of the homes captivated her even then, and those memories drew her back to the neighborhood a few years ago, when she and her husband, Mark, decided to return to Phoenix after 22 years in New York City.
“Our decision to leave New York wasn’t an easy one,” she says. “That city grows on you. But once we got back here, I said to Mark, ‘I can leave New York for this.’ ”

Willo resident Kat Soderberg and her husband, Virgil, also made a huge change when they relocated to Phoenix from Alaska in 2001. They didn’t know the city, so they lived in a corporate apartment while they familiarized themselves with the area. They, too, succumbed to the home tour, and this year their simple but stunning Mission Revival home, built in 1929, drew rave reviews from tour visitors.

“Willo is special,” Kat says, “because the residents honor the past and work together to make a better future. The people who live here are as eclectic as their houses, and we value our differences. We are there for each other in good times and bad.”

Helping One Another

And bad times there have been, most recently several months ago, when the neighborhood was hit by a small but not insignificant tragedy: a short but powerful storm, called a “microburst.” I have never seen anything like it. Winds were close to 100 miles an hour, hail came down so hard I thought all the windows in our house would break. The power went out and didn’t come back on for five days. Almost everyone in the neighborhood suffered some damage—tree limbs down, roof tiles ripped off, landscape walls collapsed. But two dear friends, Tom and Randy, a couple we met on the Home Tour Committee, suffered an unthinkable loss. An enormous, century-old pine tree fell on their beautiful home. Miraculously, no one was hurt. But their home was destroyed.

The neighborhood jumped into action. Neighbors ran in to help them salvage what personal effects they could before the house completely collapsed. The family next door gave them a place to stay while emergency services were called. Word spread quickly—it always does—and people from across the neighborhood were there to ask how they could help. Over the next three days, the streets were full of people cleaning up debris, offering to help each other, offering support. Tom and Randy are now rebuilding in the exact footprint of the original home.

Friends

As for Ryan and me, we’ve done little to the interior of our home other than make aesthetic improvements, but we’ve undertaken a fairly dramatic transformation outside to more fully embrace Willo’s “front porch” culture. Our daughter, who recently turned one, is enjoying running around on the large front patio we’ve just added. We’re out there many evenings enjoying the wonderful weather, a glass of wine and friends and neighbors walking by.

Come on over.

Katherine Bair Desmond co-chaired the 2009 Willo Historic Home Tour committee. She and her husband are expecting their second child.

Winfield, KA Glenda and Steve Campbell

campbell

When we found our wonderful 1920 “bungalow on steroids,” we had had our hearts set on an “unmolested bungalow,” but in our area they are practically nonexistent. However, it does feature oak woodwork and staircase, leaded glass, beveled glass, and original wood floors. It was originally built as a parsonage for one of the town churches. We aren’t quite sure what the official architectural style is, but after the agent showed us this house, we knew we had found our home.

Ridgefield, CT Julie and Chris Kaser

kaser

We built this Arts and Crafts bungalow in 2005 on the foundation of a 1956 ranch house. Using American Bungalow illustrations and Stickley house plans, we collaborated with our architect, James Hancock, and our builder, Neil Hicks, to design and build it. We had dreamed of living in an Arts and Crafts house for more than 20 years. Julie’s grandmother lived most of her life in a beautiful yellow brick Arts and Crafts bungalow in Oakley, Idaho, so this project ran rather deep for her. Every day in this home is a pleasure.

Green Bay, WI Ryan and Nancy Glaser

glaser

Our three-bedroom 1920s bungalow—its design inspired by English Cotswold cottages—is in Green Bay’s historic Astor District. Its features include a rolled roof, eyebrow window, built-in bookcases and window seats, crown moldings and period lighting. The house is on the National Register of Historic Places and has retained some of its original oak and maple hardwood flooring as well as Ja-Nar radiator covers and Sylphon fittings.

Front Royal, VA Maureen McHugh

mchugh

This ca. 1920 Craftsman bungalow sits in a beautiful valley in western Virginia, about a mile from Skyline Drive, in Front Royal’s historic district. With all of the original wood trim, floors, windows and many intricate handcrafted light fixtures intact, I knew immediately this was the home for me. It is so warm and cozy, I could not imagine ever living anywhere else.

Evanston, IL Susan and Bill Emrich

emrich

We purchased our 1916 bungalow in 2004 and love it more every day. While many of its original details have been removed over the years (DR built-in, living-room fireplace) enough of its original personality remains that reinforces our belief that it can look even better. Over the past few years, we painted the exterior, stripped green paint off the decorative red brick detail, enclosed the back porch and did some landscaping. This past winter we installed a fireplace using a salvaged Arts and Crafts mantel and handmade tiles. The results have been transformative and we feel lucky and proud to call this bungalow our home.

Houston, TX Gary and Annie Sitton

sitton

Our Craftsman bungalow was built in 1920 in the Heights area of Houston, where we are a short walk from the historic downtown with its wonderful art galleries, antique shops and restaurants. Before we purchased the house a couple years ago, it was known as “Toad Hall,” for the owner’s collection of toad artifacts. It is now known as “The Bunny Bungalow” because of our large collection of antique and reproduction rabbits.

This bungalow has a blog! You can view it here.

Arlington, VA Joe and Sue King

king

When we purchased our 1955 ranch in 2002 it was with the intent of eventually giving it a facelift and a bump-up with Craftsman-style details. In 2007 we transformed the mid-century house into a 1920s-era bungalow complete with front porch, period lighting and tile, salvaged doors and mantels, and reclaimed wide-plank heart-pine floors. We couldn’t be happier with the result, and we thank American Bungalow and its advertisers for helping us gain the vision to make our dream come true.

Saratoga Springs, NY Phil and Lisa Evans

evans

This is our bungalow in upstate N.Y., built in 2006. The living and dining rooms have colonnades with built-in bookcases. The kitchen has Douglas fir counters and painted period cabinets to the ceiling. It has true divided-light windows, Schoolhouse lighting, reproduction plumbing fixtures and extensive trim carpentry. Our builder was so faithful to tradition that most people think it is a restored 1920s-vintage home.



Pathetic.

Konami Easter Egg by Adrian3.com